Public Interest News Bulletin – December 10, 2010

This week: a controversial testing method for an NYC homelessness prevention program; TARP funds to prop up corporate interests, but not legal services for low-income homeowners?; the Skadden Fellowship Class of 2011 contains 29 budding public interest attorneys; funding calamity averted for D.C. legal services programs; will we lose more local/state government jobs in the recession’s wake?; significant changes in how NYC indigent defense cases are assigned to counsel; an Innocence Project report sees widespread prosecutorial misconduct in California; the Cleveland Plain Dealer looks at inefficiencies in the local criminal courts.

  • 12.6.10 – legal services advocates in the District of Columbia were bracing for an enormous cut in government funding.  A proposed austerity budget could have slashed the appropriation by over 50%.  However, in some rare good news in this arena, this week the D.C. Council came through on legal services funding.  According to our friend Jess Rosenbaum, executive director of the D.C. Access to Justice Commission, “ATJ funding was restored to approximately $3.1 million ($2.951 for grants program plus full restoration of LRAP to $221,000).  This represents a 10% cut to the ATJ grants program, as opposed to the over 50% cut that was proposed.  It also puts the FY11 level 10% higher than what was ultimately funded in FY10 ($2.639).  We are deeply grateful to the City Council for preserving funds for the program which provides critical legal services to the city’s most vulnerable residents.  However, this news is hard to celebrate in the face of horrific cuts to TANF and other programs our clients urgently rely on.”  As was reported by the Blog of the Legal Times, the ABA’s president, Stephen Zack had written in support of preserving legal services funding in D.C. Certainly this extra weight on the scale didn’t hurt.
  • 12.3.10 – Changes are afoot in New York City indigent defense case distribution.  NYC is a huge jurisdiction (jurisdictions, technically), and the assigned counsel system has always been more complex than in smaller cities.  Until very recently, no fewer than seven different entities provided indigent defense services, the largest among them being the Legal Aid Society.  There’s a shakeup, though, according to the New York Law Journal: “The distribution of indigent criminal defense cases among the groups that serve as primary providers in New York City has been significantly altered by the Office of the Criminal Justice Coordinator.  Based on figures the office has released to the groups, the Legal Aid Society will be responsible for 20,000 fewer cases, and five of the remaining six groups will receive 54,000 more.  The one group that lost out in the bidding for renewal contracts is Staten Island Defense Services, which for the past 14 years has been the primary defender of indigent cases in Richmond County.”
  • Last but not least, we regret that we missed this in-depth series from the Cleveland Plain Dealer, published last month: “In the past decade, Cuyahoga County judges have dismissed 364 cases mid-trial because they said prosecutors failed to provide the most basic evidence to sustain a conviction. The Plain Dealer examined those cases. The judges’ rulings indicate that county Prosecutor Bill Mason’s office has pushed hundreds of marginal criminal cases to trial in the past decade.”  [Emphases in original.]  It’s a five-part series, and well worth looking at if you follow the nitty-gritty workings of the criminal justice system.  Needless to say, the report generated a lot of back and forth between the prosecutor’s office (Hey, our conviction rate’s 92% and some of the blame lies with the judges), and the criminal defense bar (Those prosecutors don’t adequately screen cases).  Also, a Cuyahoga County judge threw fuel on the fire earlier this week, chiming in with an opinion piece which blames the defense bar for not taking case assignments until they’re past the indictment stage.  This piece generated some thoughtful responses in the comments section.

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine